Question by Daphane: Do you think that breed standards of some breeds have NOT changed for the better, from 1800s, 1900’s to now
The German Shepherd and the Bulldog are good examples of how different some breeds have changed from lets say the 1800s to now.
German Shepherd of the past
http://www.animalstamps.com/gsdcard/gscrd33.jpg
German Shepherd of today
http://www.akc.org/images/breeds/german_shepherd_dog/lg_artwork.jpg
Bulldog of the past
http://barkadaworkingdog.com/yahoo_site_admin/assets/images/bulldogs1800s.280210046_std.jpg
Bulldog of today
http://www.akc.org/images/breeds/bulldog/lg_artwork.jpg
Do you think the smaller hips of today’s GSD are a part of the problem of why so many GSDs these days are getting hip dysplasia?
I have heard that Bulldogs don’t live too long and are plagued with all kinds of health problems in that lifetime.
Are there any other breeds that you can think of that have changed very much from the early years to now?
Best answer:
Answer by arkpudel
The problem is not the breed standard, the problem is the interpretation of the breed standard. Some conformation folks think that if some is good, more is better. The slope of the hips is something that breeders have tried to breed more of it into the breed- because of this, yes, I think it contributes to the hip dysplasia in GSD’s. Its one reason that police departments like LRPD buy their K-9’s from Germany.
Don’t know about bulldogs, but look at the labs in the show ring today. They are larger and bulkier than the field labs. I’m not sure that a conformation lab of today could retrieve a duck if he had to, he would just sink!
Even in my breed, poodles, the hair served as a purpose in ancient times, the reason for the silly cut. However, the “if some is good, more is better” mentality, the “do’s” have just gone off the deep end. If you look at the UKC breed standard, then you will notice that they don’t care for the excess hair on today’s AKC dogs.
None of this goes against the breed standard in AKC, per se. It’s just a problem interpretation, and with breeding for “what’s en vogue”.
Know better? Leave your own answer in the comments!